What This Calculator Measures
The tool runs the full leveraged stack a landlord faces: purchase price and down payment set the loan, the loan sets the payment, and the payment sits between net operating income and the cash that actually reaches your bank account. Enter eight numbers and you get monthly cash flow after debt service, the return on the cash you wired at closing, and the unlevered cap rate on the same property — three answers that usually disagree, and the disagreements are the story.
Most single-purpose tools stop halfway. A net operating income calculator stops before financing, so it cannot tell you what a 6.5 percent mortgage does to the deal, and a payment calculator ignores whether the rent covers anything. This one connects the two sides, which is where marginal deals reveal themselves: an NOI of $18,860 looks healthy until $17,065.80 of annual debt service eats most of it.
The default scenario models a common single-family situation: a $300,000 purchase at 25 percent down, $2,400 market rent, 5 percent vacancy, and $8,500 of annual operating costs. That deal throws off $149.52 a month after the mortgage, a 2.22 percent cash-on-cash return. The numbers are deliberately thin, because that is what market-rate pricing in high-cost metros produces, and the rest of this page shows exactly which lever moves them.
The Math Behind Each Output
Payment: standard amortization, P x r / (1 - (1+r)^-n) with r the monthly rate and n the number of payments. On the default $225,000 loan at 6.5 percent over 30 years that is $1,422.15 per month. NOI: gross scheduled rent minus vacancy minus operating expenses, with financing deliberately excluded. Cap rate: NOI divided by price, 6.29 percent on the defaults.
Cash on cash: annual cash flow divided by total cash invested, where invested means the down payment plus closing costs ($81,000 on the defaults), since that is the full check you write at the table. DSCR: NOI divided by annual debt service. GRM: price divided by gross annual rent. The 1 percent rule compares monthly rent to purchase price as a screen. Each output cross-checks the others, and a deal that looks good on one but weak on another is telling you where the risk sits.
The break-even rent line solves for the rent that zeroes cash flow: (debt plus expenses) divided by (1 minus vacancy) divided by 12. On the defaults that is $2,242.61, only $157.39 below the assumed rent, so one modest rent cut or a single bad turnover month flips the deal negative. If you want the valuation angle instead of the financing angle, the cap rate calculator computes the property value implied by a market cap rate.
Cap Rate Versus Cash on Cash: Leverage Cuts Both Ways
Cap rate measures the building; cash on cash measures your equity position. The same property at $300,000 with $18,860 of NOI carries a 6.29 percent cap rate whether you pay cash or borrow 75 percent. Paid all cash, the $306,000 outlay earns $18,860 a year, 6.16 percent. With the mortgage, $81,000 earns $1,794.20 — just 2.22 percent — and you carry vacancy and interest-rate risk on top.
That gap is the cost of debt exceeding the property's unlevered yield: borrowing at an effective 6.5 percent against an asset yielding 6.29 percent subtracts value. When the spread flips — say a 7.86 percent cap rate property financed at 6.5 percent — leverage pushes cash on cash to 7.89 percent on the $240,000 comparison used later on this page. Positive leverage multiplies your return; negative leverage dilutes it while still multiplying your risk.
Lenders read the same structure through coverage, and the DSCR calculator frames that view in full. The default deal runs 1.11x, which is above water but below the 1.20x to 1.25x floor most investment-property lenders impose, meaning this loan likely needs more down payment or a lower price to close at all. Coverage near 1.0x also means any vacancy spike turns the payment into an out-of-pocket expense.
The 1 Percent Rule and Where It Fails
The rule: monthly rent at or above 1 percent of purchase price. The default deal rents at 0.80 percent — $2,400 against $300,000 — and that single number predicts the thin cash flow almost perfectly. Hitting 1 percent requires $3,000 rent on this price, which lifts cash flow to $719.52 a month and 10.66 percent cash on cash. This is why the rule survives despite ignoring almost everything that matters.
Where it fails: it ignores financing cost, expense structure, and taxes entirely. At a 5.0 percent mortgage rate, a 0.89 percent property out-earns a 1.0 percent property financed at 7.5 percent — $484.61 versus $313.08 a month — because the rate spread moves more cash than the rent ratio does. A tight 2 percent vacancy with a lean expense load can make a 0.85 percent deal work where a 12 percent expense market kills a 1.1 percent deal.
Treat it as a sorting filter, the same way the gross rent multiplier calculator sorts listings by price-to-rent without any expense detail. GRM of 8.33 on the $240,000 example versus 12.50 at $360,000 tells you in one division which listing deserves a full underwrite. Walking the price line from $240,000 to $360,000 at $2,400 rent takes cash flow from $433.95 a month to negative $134.91 — the screen and the full underwrite agree at both ends.
Vacancy and Expense Assumptions That Move the Answer
Three points of vacancy cost the default deal $72.00 a month — cash flow drops from $149.52 to $77.52 at 8 percent. Ten percent higher operating expenses ($8,500 to $9,350) costs another $70.84. Neither is catastrophic alone; combined with a 7.0 percent rate and $2,200 rent they produce a $252.10 monthly loss, and that combination is a normal bad year, not a hundred-year storm.
The old 50 percent rule — half of gross rent disappears to vacancy plus expenses — overstates the default's 34.51 percent load, because taxes, insurance, maintenance, and management vary enormously by market and asset age. Underwrite each line from county tax records, an actual insurance quote, and 8 to 12 percent of collected rent for management. Short-term rentals need a different shape of assumption entirely: seasonal occupancy does the work of a vacancy rate and then some.
For portfolio-level occupancy patterns across units or seasons, the occupancy rate calculator frames the percentage you should carry into this tool. Whatever rate you choose, hold it constant when comparing two candidate properties, or the comparison quietly measures your assumptions instead of the buildings. The same discipline applies to the expense line: taxes reprice on sale, so use your post-purchase assessment, not the seller's.
Financing Levers: Down Payment, Rate, and Term
Down payment works through two channels at once: less debt lifts the numerator (cash flow) while more equity inflates the denominator (cash invested). At 15 percent down the default deal bleeds $40.10 a month and covers its debt only 0.98x; at 30 percent down it throws off $244.33 monthly at 3.05 percent cash on cash. More down rescues the payment but drags the yield on each dollar you invest — a fair trade only when the alternative use of that cash earns less.
Rate dominates everything else: the same property swings from $363.82 a month at 5.0 percent to negative $1.56 at 7.5 percent, a $365.38 swing on 250 basis points. Term trades cash flow for equity speed: the 30-year at 6.5 percent leaves $149.52 monthly, while a 15-year at 6.0 percent runs $1,898.68 payments and negative $327.01 flow, retiring the loan in half the time instead. Neither choice is wrong; just do not confuse the second one with an investment return.
If you plan extra principal later, the mortgage amortization calculator shows exactly when each prepayment shifts the crossover. When comparing lender offers here, points and origination fees belong in the closing-costs field, since they are real cash out at the table and they change cash on cash even though the rate looks identical. A quarter-point bought for two points is a worse deal than it appears on the rate sheet.
Taxes, Depreciation, and After-Tax Cash Flow
The tool prices pre-tax cash flow, but depreciation often flips the tax picture. On the default deal, assuming 75 percent of the $300,000 price is depreciable building ($225,000 over 27.5 years), the write-off is $8,181.82 a year. Year-one interest of $14,550.96 plus that depreciation exceeds the $18,860 NOI by $3,872.78, so the property reports a paper loss while the checks still arrive — that loss can shelter other passive income.
The shelter is not free money: it defers tax through a lower basis, and the depreciation portion is generally recaptured at sale at up to 25 percent unless a 1031 exchange intervenes. Rental losses are also passive, subject to the $25,000 offset that phases out between $100,000 and $150,000 of modified adjusted gross income and to active-participation rules. Verify your own position with a tax professional before counting the deduction as cash.
Nothing in the tool's outputs counts appreciation, and that is honest: price growth is neither cash flow nor guaranteed. Over a long hold it often dominates total return, and the appreciation calculator prices that side separately. A deal justified only by projected appreciation is a speculation, and a deal justified only by 2 percent cash on cash is a bond with toilets; most good purchases need both stories to be true.
A Screening Workflow From Listing to Offer
Sort first: run the 1 percent ratio or GRM across every listing in the target zip and kill 80 percent in a minute. Underwrite the survivors here with full expenses — county taxes, an insurance quote, 8 percent management, 5 to 8 percent vacancy. Then stress the finalist: 8 percent vacancy, expenses up 10 percent, and today's rate plus 50 basis points. If it still shows positive flow, write your offer around the price that returns your target cash on cash at your actual down payment.
Two costs sellers love to hide belong in specific fields. The tenant-placement fee belongs in operating expenses — the rental commission calculator prices the common leasing conventions — and deferred maintenance belongs in the purchase price, because a failing roof is not an operating expense, it is a price correction. For distressed candidates, the ARV calculator frames what the property is worth once the work is done; buy off that number, not the asking one.
Financing shopping is the last lever: run the winning deal at two or three quotes with identical down payment and rank by monthly cash flow, not headline rate, since points and fees move the closing-costs input. A plain mortgage calculator confirms each payment independently. The deal that survives every one of these gates is rare — that is the entire point of running the sequence.